There are two reasons a free country needs borders. We know that Guantanamo Bay currently has space. They can make or destroy a country. Both of our borders, northern and southern, are a source of anxiety with regard to terror. We need … Yet even if we did that, our free country would still need borders because, as I said, most countries will not ensure freedom as America’s Constitution attempted to do. Humans just document/record borders in a more sophisticated manner. But things have gone so bonkers and so crazy in recent times, it forces us to state or restate what should have been obvious all along. These European colonists created the borders of most African countries. If people enter the country illegally, we cannot effectively control any disease they may carry. But borders are also an example of structural violence, of using a system of laws and regulations that deprive other people of opportunities through the imposition of borders… In fact, the vast majority of countries in the world today – including the United States – are not consistently and absolutely free. Today’s leftists don’t want borders for obvious reasons. How come we can’t be free? Search under “Michael Hurd” (Rehoboth Beach DE). The more the better, in fact — except that we need people who will become employed and be the solutions to our problems and not add to the problems. The troops will help secure the border from illegal immigration, a decision that will protect the American people from foreign and domestic threats. Yet even if we did that, our free country would still need borders because, as I said, most countries will not ensure freedom as America’s Constitution attempted to do. Most of the wall isn't 'wall' at all. Russian there is. is provided to you, There's No Stopping America's Political Realignment, Ninth Circuit: LAPD Officer Can Be Sued For Destroying Gun Collection, WHISTLEBLOWER: I Drove 'Thousands of Ballots' From New York to Pennsylvania, 'Are YOU drunk?' Who is going to pick up the tab for this? However, deportation lawyers drag this out and we shouldn’t let them. Get up-to-the-minute postings, recommended articles and links, and engage in back-and-forth discussion with Dr. Hurd on topics of interest. Trump has offered a common sense fix for the DACA dilemma. ... two-thirds of the land along the border … And to denote the limits of your territory, you need a border. The second aspect is preventing the potential spread of infectious diseases being brought to the United States. If people enter the country illegally, we cannot effectively control any disease they may carry. I can hardly believe I even had to write this article. That’s the only consistent way for the country to be called a free country. Illegal drugs, weapons, terrorists, and criminal gangs are pouring into the United States through our unsecured border. China’s move to build a road through a disputed area in the Himalayas a couple of weeks ago set off a string of military escalations and left 3,000 Indian and Chinese troops(each) staring each other down. I mean, a lot of people need this more than we do, and if we open the borders we could help a lot of people. But even if we begin to understand this, the main reason that hard borders aren’t going anywhere, Longo argues, has nothing to do with either economics or populism. What do we need to know about the border wall? It might be #1, but that is not for me to say. While the Trump administration has said the wall is necessary to curb illegal immigration and … Borders are a form of global apartheid. Get up-to-the-minute postings, recommended articles and links, and engage in back-and-forth discussion with Dr. Hurd on topics of interest. Individuals are either in the country legally or illegally – there is no gray area. President Trump is sending national guard troops to protect America’s southern border. It’s important to examine some of the broken immigration policies that Congress must immediately address. Their true intentions are not to allow “dreamers” to live in self-responsible liberty, but rather to ensure that as many become as dependent on the government entitlement state as possible, ensuring permanent electoral victories. Boundaries are desirable even necessary. In order to survive, states need borders (self-organization) – “operational closure.”. Many in the media mistook their lip service for accomplishment. Border security is and has always been an important part of the debate on immigration policy. Border issues often arise when outside powers draw borders in regions they colonize, with or without the consent of the people who already live there. For example, a dictatorship might seek to dump its derelicts on a free country. In order to survive, states need borders (self-organisation) - "operational closure". You wouldn’t want to see these two countries go to war, given their nuclear weapons and combined population of 2.7 billion people. Sending 4,000 national guard troops to our southern border is action, and actions speak louder than words. Many people coming across America’s southern border are in need of welfare services. Keeping borders open throws states in disarray. In a strange way it might be good, because with everything going down the tubes, perhaps the stage will be set for a return to reason and liberty as America’s wise founders originally envisioned. All Rights Reserved. As well as scaling back his ambitions for the length of the border … Where are we going to put them? By contrast, there is a need for … But others say that competition is exactly why we need tariff-free trade, because it lowers the prices of all the day-to-day stuff we buy, like food. My point: National borders were not and are not the “natural” way of breaking up territory. Please tell me how a person who doesn’t have the means to support themselves and does not speak proper English is going to be anything other than a burden on society? No enemies, no violent conflict …. Georgia Governor Changes Tune After Trump Lawyers Present Troubling Video of Alleged Fraud, Townhall.com is the leading source for conservative news and political commentary and analysis. In a free country, can’t people just move about freely, at will? Borders are very important for political and economic reasons. ... the Department of Defense has reprogrammed $6.1 billion for wall construction. Borders are required to provide objective and discernible boundaries between free countries and less free, or totally unfree, countries. Keeping borders open throws states into disarray. So even if every country in the world were free, there would still be terrorists, criminals and others who intend to do harm to innocent victims. The only solution, obviously, is to repeal the welfare state altogether, demanding that no charity be coerced and all schools and medical care either be privately funded or based on voluntary charity. This is not surprising, given the exponential increase in agents in recent years. Borders were important when we made our decisions. President Trump says what he means and means what he says. In 2011, a report from the Senate Homeland Security Committee found that the Canadian border gives “easy passage into America by extremists, terrorists and criminals whose purpose clearly is to harm the American people.” Systems science describes biological and social (man-made) systems. Those policies should begin today. 'I'll Develop Some Disease And Say I Have To Resign', Alito responds to PA appeal — but there’s just one catch, CCPA - Do not sell my personal information. David A. Clarke Jr. is President of DAC Enterprise LLC and senior advisor/spokesman for America First Action PAC/Policies. In the end, the only answer will be the one most don’t want to consider, because it seems too radical: Repeal most of what the federal government currently does, and go back to the original Constitution, where the federal government provides for a national defense, border control and that’s pretty much about it. Why do we need customs? In sum, borders matter not only in an instrumental sense but in a symbolic sense as well, both for the state’s assertion of power and legitimacy and in the way citizens imagine their nations as limited sovereign communities. This is a strain on limited public resources like medical services, schools, and yes, the criminal justice system. So we need immigration. Thankfully, Trump recently signed a memorandum ensuring an end to the “catch and release” policy. Also follow Dr. Hurd on Twitter at @MichaelJHurd1. Two, not everyone is good. Yes, we need a better immigration system that controls immigration, and a … By “right kind” I mean that some discrimination is used to ensure that likely or known criminals can be kept out. Borders are neither desirable nor necessary. This has already happened in places like California and, on our present course, even with Donald Trump in office, it’s inevitable for the country as a whole. Follow Dr. Hurd on Facebook. Trump was right when he said some countries do not always send us their best and brightest – most immigrants are not self-sufficient. Borders therefore are a natural byproduct of territorialism. Studying border changes is not just an academic exercise. In this respect, the borders of North America are no different from other borders of the world. The Channel: The final frontier of the Schengen Zone. Cuomo Alleges the Trump Admin 'Created the Cynicism' Around the Vaccine, Obama Sends Mixed Messages on AOC and 'Defund the Police', Project Veritas Exposes How CNN Reacted to the Hunter Biden Story, Sen. Blackburn Reacts After Chinese State Media Send Her Foul Messages, WATCH: Biden's Disturbing Answer on How He'll Resolve Fundamental Differences With Kamala Harris, Biden Reveals How Long He Expects Americans to Wear Face Masks, Did Biden Just Say the Quiet Part Out Loud? August 23, 2016. Well, I'm not really sure how would a "borderless country" work, the very definition of a "country" in most dictionaries is tied to territory (i.e. But if this is the case, why do we need any border tax? Congress needs to exhibit the same sense of urgency that he has. Mitigate the fears of many Americans that occur with an open border. Past presidents from both parties spewed hot air about what we needed to do yet they never did much. That’s the last thing proponents of “immigration reform” or open borders want, and it’s revealing because it shows their true intentions. Trump has approached the very solemn duty of protecting the American people by doing what most politicians won’t: actually defending our borders. Like, come on people, why not? Trump has provided for more agents and judges to clean up this backlog and we should monitor it closely for results through benchmarks of success. In order to prevent such diseases from turning into a pandemic, we started monitoring people for symptoms coming into the country – that’s border enforcement. Or someone might develop an ideology sworn to destroy freedom and liberty wherever they find it, making members of that ideology seeking to enter the free country suspect, at best. He formerly served as the Sheriff of Milwaukee County. There is often the question why we need borders? Countries have gone to war over border disputes including airspace. The calculations can't shed full light on why countries don't try more aggressively to eliminate borders, but they do explore the purely economic costs and benefits of doing so. The border agencies of a free country exist to ensure that only the right kind of people get into that free country. They were arbitrary servants to the invented political idea of the nation state. Borders preserve the privilege of the wealthy at the expense … While our world today is too complex for the free-flowing anarchic state of thousands, even hundreds of years ago, boundaries would suffice for administrative purposes. Illegal aliens should be detained pending their deportation hearing, and should not be allowed to walk among the public, use public services, and take jobs away from American citizens. Brother became successful, raised a family, and has at least one grandchild. On one of my trips to the border, I asked my escorts, a couple of border patrol agents, if they thought we needed a border wall. 1 Because our immigration system is universally regarded as "broken." One, they claim to believe that everyone is the same, and that it’s automatically and always “racist” or otherwise irrational to make any kind of judgments at all. Many people are asking: Do we need a border wall? States are “social systems,” constituted and maintained by borders, border control, and order within states. Specifically, we need more efficient and cost-effective measures that identify those who seek to do us harm and keep them out or apprehend them. America is a sovereign nation, one that is discernible by its identifiable borders that must be secured and defended. For example, the spread of the Zika virus from South America and the H1N1 or swine flu outbreak from several years ago were in part spread by immigration. States are "social systems", constituted and maintained by borders, border control, and order within states. We have a president who is going to do more than pay lip service to our broken immigration system like his previous three predecessors had done. North American borders, however, are unique since they divide one of the earth’s seven continents into three large and important nation-states that differ in significant ways from one another. Systems science describes biological and social (man-made) systems. Cambridge definition of country is "an area of land that has its own government, army, etc."). We should open the borders for undocumented people that want to and need to go back to their families. During the 1800s and 1900s, European countries colonized much of Africa. Today’s open-borders agenda has its roots not only in economic and political factors — the need for low-wage workers who will do the work that native-born Americans or Europeans supposedly … Well, you can be free, but the domain of freedom is not unlimited. And don’t free people want everyone to come into their country?”. This can be achieved by defining a secure border, creating a secure border system and adopting measures to determine success. The road runs through disputed territory in trying-to-mind-its-own-business Bhutan—but give… … I was not so well-driven, and came back to the USA when Jimmy Carter said I could do so---on parole. The third reason that border control is necessary is to deter the influx of another country’s ne’er-do-wells. The American taxpayer will. Nations don't want to share institutions, lose their culture and values, or see their sovereignty dissolve. Two, they know full well that with open borders the most needy and dependent will enter the nation in order to exploit that nation’s welfare and entitlement programs, including but not limited to “free” schools, health care and all the rest. We read news stories all the time about air space being violated. Why animals have to be territorial ==> ask Darwin / evolution Apparently it's … The next best solution would be to deny the “freebie” benefits to immigrants and let them either fend for themselves or rely on voluntary charity. Expect a Preservationist, Climate-Centered Agency, Beloved Coach Lou Holtz Receives the Medal of Freedom, BREAKING: Top White House Communications Official Resigns, COVID Damage Control, Not 'Fact-Checking', DOJ Cracks Down on Facebook Discrimination, Trump Attorneys Produce Video Alleging Georgia Ballots Were Hidden in Suitcases, An Unlikely Ally: Democrat Defends President Trump Over Section 230, Delusional Never Trump Losers Think We’re Going to Take Them Back, Gov. Sometimes this domain is very small, like in a prison cell, at other times you can go from one place to another almost without any confines. In the El Paso sector, 3.5 migrants were arrested per agent. Politicians, journalists and … We … That’s how serious countries take their sovereignty. Why We Need Sound Border Security Policies. The growth of the dangerous criminal gang MS-13 was in part the result of a defective Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program and other illegal southern border crossings. There are three major reasons America needs to protect and secure its borders: security, health, and American jobs. It is deeply unfashionable to claim that immigration is a threat to our culture, as, after all, almost all American… Like in the European Economic Area, where there is a free flow of labour and goods, there is no tax to bring something form one country to another, but if it comes from e.g. When it comes to border security and management, we need smart enforcement that is humane and transparent and takes into account the daily impact on the 15 million people who live along our borders. Imagine … a borderless world …. Oftentimes, unscrupulous employers victimize U.S. citizens by providing jobs and safe havens for illegal aliens – a criminal act. Not only is this a great policy decision, but it’s a strategic one that puts America first. That said, a good starting point is the number of people US Customs and Border Protection (CBP) apprehend at the southern border. They emphasized to me their support for a wall. Answered May 21, 2016. One, not all other countries are free. And even if all countries became permanently and totally free, we’d still need borders, at least until the entire world came to agreement about living on a planet dedicated to liberty and individual rights. Borders are very important for territorial sovereignty, they also help get immigration and emigration. Copyright © Townhall.com/Salem Media. The most important aspect of immigration reform is keeping America safe. Trump’s recent actions need to be supplemented with more speedy and effective processing of people who illegally trespass into our country. The backlog has got to be cleaned up through a streamlined deportation process. Congress still shows no sense of urgency about this crisis, instead choosing to use it as campaign leverage going into November. His four pillars include: capping chain migration, ending the visa lottery program, mandating employment e-verification, and harshly fining employers who circumvent the law. Why We Need the Border Wall In Foreign Policy , Front Page , Illegal immigration , Immigration , National Security by Allen West November 16, 2018 I find it amazing that the progressive socialist left was able to shift the prevailing narrative of the 2018 midterm elections from the economy and border security. Some people have asked, “Why does a truly free country need borders? Apparently, that isn’t the case here in the United States. We only need borders because we have nation states. Terms under which this service Mean girl Soledad O’Brien's attempt at smearing Trump witness Mellissa Carone does NOT end well for her, like at all, Celebrity Chef Who's Defying COVID-19 Restrictions Fires Back at Critics: 'I'm Not the A**hole, the Governor Is', Trump Lawyers Allege in New Lawsuit That 40,000 Voted Twice in Nevada Election, Who Will Lead Biden's Interior Dept.? Would it make sense to get rid of that tax too, if every single country in the world would do it too? Nor is it surprising that DHS has not seen the need to request additional Border Patrol agents.